Price Shopping Could Cut Employer Health Costs By 20%, But There's A Catch
Need an MRI? It pays to shop around. Big time.
In fact, not all MRIs are alike, a point made clear in a riveting new study in the peer-reviewed Spine Journal. The unusual study design involved a “secret shopper” scenario in which a 63-year-old woman with lower back pain obtained 10 different MRIs over a period of three weeks, all from different imaging centers in her region.
The results: each of the 10 centers reported a different set of diagnoses and different treatment plans, for a total of 49 different findings about this one woman’s back. Some centers missed a problem they should have detected, and others found a problem where none existed. Treatment recommendations also varied, with some likely to accomplish nothing and several so risky they would likely have made the patient’s situation far worse.
Though the researchers didn’t report on the price charged for each of these MRIs, they told me in general they found that price does not predict the accuracy of the diagnosis.
The AHCA Gets It Wrong: Health Care Is Different
A study in the Spine Journal this month reported that MRIs on one patient’s lumbar spine at 10 different imaging centers in New York City showed variability in how the findings were interpreted and a "high prevalence" of errors in interpretation.
Making matters worse for consumers: Quality is not necessarily correlated with price, says Binder.
"Not all MRIs are created equal," agrees Binder.
Marked Variability in Diagnostic Interpretation of Lumbar Spine MRI Found
Continuing in our role as a thought leader shaping discussions of quality healthcare, Spreemo Health reached the center of the ongoing national debate on healthcare reform when Dr. Robert Berenson, former vice-chair of MedPAC and current member of PTAC, featured our landmark Spine Journal study as the cornerstone of his analysis of the AHCA in a piece for Health Affairs, described by the Washington Post as the “bible of healthcare policy”. No matter where you stand on the AHCA, our study raises critical questions of quality and value that you cannot ignore.
Spreemo Health Launches Spine Radiology Network to Raise Standard of Spine Care
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of a single patient’s lumbar spine at 10 different MRI centers showed marked variability in reported interpretive findings and a high prevalence of interpretive errors, according to a prospective observational study published online ahead of print in The Spine Journal.
Spreemo Health’s Lead Radiologist Honored for Contributions to New York Healthcare
New program to improve outcomes and reduce diagnostic errors for patients with back pain
Radiology Network, answering the overwhelming demand from Fortune 500 employers and other payers for an innovative healthcare solution that leverages the company’s cutting-edge quality analytics to address one of the world’s leading causes of disability: chronic back pain.
NEW YORK (February 23, 2017)—Richard Herzog, MD, Executive Director of the Spreemo Health Quality Research Institute, was recently honored with a Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) “Promoting Health and Wellness” Award from City & State New York to recognize his efforts in increasing the quality of diagnostic care both in New York and throughout the country.